Question 3
Incorporation of termsMediumA man telephones a sports club and books a squash court for the following evening, agreeing the £12 fee on the call. He has played at the club four times over the past year. When he arrives he pays at reception and changes in the locker room, where a notice in small print above the lockers states: 'The club accepts no responsibility for loss of or damage to members' property.' While he plays, another user forces his locker and steals his watch.
Can the club rely on the notice to defeat the man's claim for the value of the watch?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer B
Correct answer
No, because the contract was concluded on the telephone, before the notice could be seen.
The notice came too late: the contract was made on the telephone before the man could see it.
Incorporation by notice requires the notice to be given at or before the time the contract is made. The court booking and the fee were agreed during the call, so the locker-room notice, seen only on arrival, is not a term.
The booking and fee were agreed on the call, so the contract was complete before the man ever entered the locker room; a notice seen afterwards cannot become a term.
- Olley v Marlborough Court Ltd — Notice given after the contract has been made does not incorporate the term.
Rule card
Notice cases: identify the moment of contracting; a notice given later cannot be incorporated, however prominent or clear.
Why the other options fail
- AAdjacent rule
No, because the wording does not clearly cover theft by another user.
Construction only arises once the term is part of the contract, and 'loss of or damage to members' property' would in any event naturally extend to theft.
- Hollier v Rambler Motors (AMC) Ltd — Ambiguity in an exemption clause is construed against the party relying on it.
- CSurface readingClosest alternative
Yes, because the notice was displayed in the locker room where users would reasonably be expected to see it.
Reasonable notice must be given before or at the time of contracting; a notice first encountered after the booking was made on the telephone comes too late.
Ruled out by: The man agreed the booking and the £12 fee on the telephone the previous day, so the contract was already complete before he reached the locker room.
- Parker v South Eastern Railway Co — A term is incorporated by notice if reasonable steps were taken to bring it to the other party's attention at the time of contracting.
- DAdjacent rule
No, because a clause as onerous as this printed in small print had to be specifically drawn to his attention.
The special notice rule applies to unusual or extortionate clauses where notice is given in time; here the notice was given after the contract, so the timing rule disposes of it.
- Interfoto Picture Library Ltd v Stiletto Visual Programmes Ltd — An unusually onerous clause must be specifically drawn to the other party's attention if it is to be incorporated by notice.
- EAdjacent rule
Yes, because his four previous visits over the past year established a course of dealing incorporating the notice.
Four occasional visits over the course of a year fall well short of the regular and consistent dealing required to incorporate an exclusion clause into a consumer contract by course of dealing.
- Hollier v Rambler Motors (AMC) Ltd — A small number of transactions over an extended period does not establish a course of dealing sufficient to incorporate terms into a consumer contract.