FLK1, Session 2 · Parties

SQE1 Contract Law question: Privity of contract

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 2

Privity of contractMedium

A carrier contracted with the owner of a cargo of machinery to carry it by sea. Clause 7 of the bill of lading provided that every servant, agent and independent contractor employed by the carrier should have the benefit of the clause limiting liability for damage to cargo to £1,000 per package. Stevedores engaged by the carrier to unload the cargo dropped a crate, destroying machinery worth £40,000. The owner sues the stevedores in negligence for £40,000.

Which of the following best describes the stevedores' position?

Show the answer and explanation
C

Correct answer

The stevedores may rely on the limitation clause under the 1999 Act, since the term expressly confers its benefit on independent contractors.

A limitation clause expressed to benefit a described class of third parties may be relied on by a member of that class under s.1(6).

Clause 7 purports to confer the benefit of the £1,000 limitation on independent contractors employed by the carrier, a description satisfying s.1(3); s.1(6) allows the stevedores to avail themselves of that limitation without proving agency or consideration.

The clause purports to confer a benefit on a class answering a particular description, so the stevedores may avail themselves of the limitation.

  • Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999, s.1(6) — Third parties may avail themselves of exclusion and limitation clauses.

Rule card

s.1(6): where a term excludes or limits liability, a third party identified by name, class or description may avail himself of it, replacing the need for the agency devices used before 1999.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    The stevedores cannot rely on the clause because they are not named in the contract.

    Identification as a member of a class or by description is sufficient; 'independent contractor employed by the carrier' is such a description.

    • Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999, s.1(3) — Identification by class or description suffices.
  • B
    Outdated lawClosest alternative

    The stevedores cannot rely on the clause unless they can show an agency relationship with the carrier.

    That was the route the common law required before the 1999 Act; the statutory right now allows the third party to avail itself of the clause directly.

    Ruled out by: Clause 7 expressly extends the limitation to independent contractors employed by the carrier, so the statutory route applies and no agency analysis is needed.

    • New Zealand Shipping Co Ltd v A M Satterthwaite & Co Ltd (The Eurymedon) — Before the 1999 Act a stevedore could take the benefit of an exclusion clause only by establishing a collateral contract made through the carrier as agent.
  • D
    Surface reading

    The stevedores cannot rely on the clause because the owner's claim against them is framed in negligence rather than contract.

    The Act allows the third party to avail itself of an exclusion or limitation in relation to the matter covered, including a claim in negligence for cargo damage.

    • Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999, s.1(6) — A third party may avail himself of a term excluding or limiting liability in relation to the matter concerned.
  • E
    Outdated law

    The stevedores cannot rely on the clause because they gave no consideration to the goods' owner.

    Consideration from the third party is not required for the statutory right to avail itself of an exclusion or limitation.

    • Scruttons Ltd v Midland Silicones Ltd — At common law a stranger to the contract who gave no consideration could not rely on its limitation clause.

Read with this question