Question 1
CertaintyEasierOver lunch, the owner of a restaurant orally agreed with a wine merchant to buy 'a quantity of the 2019 vintage of a named Rioja, at the trade price applicable on delivery, on the usual terms'. The two businesses had never dealt with each other before, and there is no established trade practice as to what 'the usual terms' means. Nothing was written down and no wine has been delivered. The merchant wishes to sue the restaurant owner.
Which of the following best describes whether a contract has been formed?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer C
Correct answer
There is no contract, because the quantity and the 'usual terms' are not ascertainable from the agreement or trade practice.
With no ascertainable quantity and no means of giving content to 'the usual terms', the agreement is too uncertain to be a contract.
There were no previous dealings and no trade practice to define 'the usual terms', and the quantity was left wholly open. The court cannot determine what the parties bound themselves to, so no contract was formed. While an objective price benchmark such as the trade price on delivery is sufficiently certain, the failure to identify any quantity or terms of dealing prevents contract formation.
No quantity was fixed and there was no prior dealing or trade practice by which 'the usual terms' could be given content, so the court cannot identify what was agreed and the agreement fails for uncertainty.
- Scammell & Nephew Ltd v Ouston — Language too vague to be given a definite meaning prevents the formation of a contract.
- Hillas & Co Ltd v Arcos Ltd — The court will uphold an informal commercial bargain where its terms can be ascertained.
Rule card
An agreement fails for uncertainty where its essential terms cannot be given a definite meaning. Prior dealings, trade custom, a standard of reasonableness or part performance may cure vagueness; a meaningless but severable phrase may be struck out.
Why the other options fail
- AAdjacent rule
There is a binding contract, because the Sale of Goods Act 1979 provides that the buyer must pay a reasonable price.
Section 8(2) of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 provides that where the price is not determined, the buyer must pay a reasonable price. However, this statutory gap-filler applies only where a valid contract has otherwise been concluded; it cannot cure the fatal uncertainty of an unascertainable quantity and terms.
- Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 8 — A buyer must pay a reasonable price where price is not determined, but this applies only where a contract has otherwise formed.
- May and Butcher Ltd v The King — Statutory implication of a reasonable price cannot cure an agreement that is void for uncertainty on essential terms.
- BAdjacent rule
There is a binding contract, because the court will imply whatever quantity, delivery and payment terms are reasonable in the circumstances.
The court will strive to uphold a bargain the parties have acted on, but it will not write the contract for them where the quantity and terms cannot be ascertained at all.
- Scammell & Nephew Ltd v Ouston — Where the language used is so vague that no definite meaning can be given, there is no contract.
- DAdjacent rule
There is no contract, because fixing the price by reference to the trade price on delivery leaves the price uncertain.
An agreement to purchase goods at the trade price applicable on delivery provides an objective benchmark by which the price can be determined, so the pricing term is not uncertain. The agreement fails instead because no quantity was agreed and the 'usual terms' cannot be identified.
- Foley v Classique Coaches Ltd — An agreement to supply goods at an ascertainable market or trade price is sufficiently certain to be binding.
- EAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
There is a binding contract, because the vague phrase can be severed and the remainder enforced.
Severance is possible only where the meaningless phrase is self-contained and the rest of the bargain is complete; here the quantity itself is unascertainable.
Ruled out by: Severance cannot save the agreement because the quantity is also unfixed, so even without the vague phrase nothing definite remains.
- Nicolene Ltd v Simmonds — A meaningless and severable clause may be disregarded without destroying an otherwise complete contract.