FLK2, Sessions 1 and 2 · Client money

SQE1 Solicitors Accounts question: Repayment

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 1

RepaymentMedium

A solicitor acts for a client buying a small office unit. At the outset the client transferred £2,000 to the firm on account of costs and disbursements, which was paid into the general client account. During the matter the firm paid a search fee of £280 and a Land Registry fee of £135, both from the client account. Before the client's money was received, the firm had paid a surveyor's fee of £240 from its business account; the surveyor is not registered for VAT. The firm also incurred £15 in postage, which it treats as an office expense and does not charge to the client. The matter has concluded. The firm has delivered a bill for profit costs of £900 plus VAT of £180, together with the surveyor's fee of £240, and has transferred the amount of that bill from the client account to the business account.

What sum must the firm now return to the client?

Show the answer and explanation
E

Correct answer

£265, the balance remaining on the client ledger.

Work through the client ledger: receipt £2,000, two disbursements paid from client account, then transfer of the delivered bill, leaving £265 to be returned.

£2,000 − £280 − £135 = £1,585. The delivered bill totals £900 + £180 VAT + £240 surveyor's fee = £1,320, properly transferred to business. £1,585 − £1,320 = £265, which must be returned promptly as there is no longer any proper reason to hold it. The £15 postage is an office expense and is not charged to the client.

£2,000 less the £280 search fee, less the £135 registration fee, less the billed £1,320 (£900 + £180 VAT + £240 surveyor's fee) leaves £265, which must be returned promptly.

  • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 2.5 — Client money must be returned promptly to the client as soon as there is no longer any proper reason to hold those funds.

Rule card

Repayment: once the bill has been transferred and disbursements paid, any residual client money must be returned promptly under rule 2.5.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Surface reading

    £680, being the sum left on the client account ledger.

    This deducts only the £1,320 bill from £2,000 and ignores the £280 search fee and £135 registration fee already paid from the client account.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 5.3 — Client money may only be withdrawn if sufficient funds are held for that specific client, so payments out reduce the sum available for repayment.
  • B
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    £505, the amount standing to the client's credit after the transfer.

    This transfers only £1,080 of costs and VAT, leaving the billed surveyor's fee of £240 in the client account when it is now the firm's money.

    Ruled out by: The surveyor's fee of £240 was included in the delivered bill, so it is the firm's money and is transferred out rather than left on the client ledger.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 2.1(d) — Money for fees and unpaid disbursements is client money only if held before delivery of a bill for the same.
  • C
    Surface reading

    £445, the amount remaining to the client's credit after the transfer of costs.

    This leaves the £180 VAT in the client account; 'fees' include the VAT element, so the whole of the billed amount is transferable to business.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 2.1(d) — Client money includes money held in respect of fees, which comprise profit costs including any VAT element, before a bill is delivered.
  • D
    Surface reading

    £400, the balance on the client ledger.

    This deducts the £280 search fee but not the £135 registration fee, both of which were paid from the client account.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 5.1(a) — Client money may be withdrawn from a client account for the purpose for which it is held, such as paying the client's disbursements.

Read with this question