Question 1
Core knowledge areas of freehold real estate law and practiceHarderA woman owned a freehold farm comprising a farmhouse, a barn and twelve acres of pasture, all in one registered title. She occupied the whole of the farm herself, living in the farmhouse and farming the pasture. Two years ago she sold the converted barn, now a dwelling, to a man. The barn's foul drainage runs beneath the pasture to a septic tank in the corner of the field; two inspection chambers stand clearly visible in the pasture, and the drain was in use serving the barn on the day of the sale. The transfer of the barn was made by deed, contained no express grant of easements, and expressly excluded the operation of s.62 of the Law of Property Act 1925. Nothing about drainage has ever been noted on either registered title. There is also a grass track across the pasture which the woman had sometimes used to reach the barn, although the barn has its own tarmac drive onto the public highway. The woman now intends to block the drain and dig up the pipe.
Which of the following best describes the man's rights in respect of the drainage?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer E
Correct answer
He has a legal easement of drainage, impliedly granted by the transfer because the drain was continuous, apparent and in use at the sale.
The drainage passes by implied grant under the rule in Wheeldon v Burrows on the sale of part and, being implied into the transfer of the legal estate, is a legal easement.
Under the rule in Wheeldon v Burrows, on a sale of part, quasi-easements that are continuous and apparent, in use at the time of the sale, and necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of the land sold pass by implied grant into the transfer deed, creating a legal easement. The drain served the barn, was in use at the sale, was continuous and apparent from the visible inspection chambers, and foul drainage is necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of the dwelling. Because it is implied into a deed transferring a legal estate, it takes effect as a legal easement.
The visible inspection chambers made the drain continuous and apparent, it was in use at the date of sale and drainage is necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of a dwelling. As the grant is implied into a deed transferring a legal estate, it creates a legal easement.
- Wheeldon v Burrows — Implied grant of continuous and apparent quasi-easements on a sale of part.
Rule card
Sale of part: Wheeldon v Burrows implies grants of quasi-easements that are continuous and apparent, in use at the date of the transfer, and necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of the land sold.
Why the other options fail
- ARight outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative
He has a legal easement of drainage, because s.62 of the Law of Property Act 1925 passed the right enjoyed with the barn.
Although s.62 of the Law of Property Act 1925 can imply easements for continuous and apparent rights such as drains into a conveyance, its operation was expressly excluded by the transfer deed.
Ruled out by: A claim under s.62 of the Law of Property Act 1925 fails because the transfer deed expressly excluded the operation of that section.
- Law of Property Act 1925, s.62 — A conveyance of land having buildings thereon operates to convey drains enjoyed with the land, unless excluded.
- BSurface reading
He has no easement of drainage, because an underground pipe cannot satisfy the requirement of being continuous and apparent.
Under Wheeldon v Burrows, quasi-easements must be continuous and apparent; although the pipe itself is buried beneath the pasture, the presence of visible inspection chambers satisfies the requirement of being apparent upon an inspection of the land.
- Wheeldon v Burrows — Quasi-easements pass on a sale of part where they are continuous and apparent, necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of the property, and in use at the date of the grant.
- CAdjacent rule
He has an equitable easement only, because the right of drainage has never been noted on the register.
A right impliedly granted by the transfer of the legal estate is itself legal; the absence of an entry on the register does not reduce it to an equitable interest.
- Wheeldon v Burrows — The implied grant takes effect as part of the conveyance of the legal estate.
- DSurface reading
He has legal easements of both the drainage and the grass track, since each was being used for the benefit of the barn when it was sold.
The track fails the requirement of necessity for reasonable enjoyment because the barn has its own direct access to the highway.
- Wheeldon v Burrows — An implied grant requires the right to be necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of the land sold.