Question 5
Registration requirements and issue of VAT invoicesMediumA solicitor acts for a company which owns three blocks of flats and whose only business is letting them to private tenants on residential tenancies. Its rental income for the last 12 months was £250,000. It paid £30,000 of VAT on invoices from maintenance contractors, whose invoices are addressed to the company's managing agent. The company's accountant has described the rents as 'zero-rated' and has told the director that some businesses register for VAT voluntarily simply so that they can recover input tax.
Which of the following best describes the company's VAT position?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer E
Correct answer
The company cannot register for VAT, because it makes only exempt supplies, so the £30,000 is not recoverable.
A business making only exempt supplies cannot register for VAT and cannot recover input tax.
Residential letting is an exempt supply, so the company makes no taxable supplies whatever the level of its rents. It therefore cannot register, voluntarily or otherwise, and the £30,000 of VAT charged by its contractors is irrecoverable.
Residential lettings are exempt supplies; a person making only exempt supplies cannot register and cannot reclaim any input tax.
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, s.4(2) — A taxable supply is a supply other than an exempt supply, and supplies of residential land are exempt.
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, s.4(1) — VAT is charged only on taxable supplies made by a taxable person in the course or furtherance of business.
Rule card
Exempt supply: no output tax, no registration, no input tax recovery. Zero-rated supply: no VAT charged to customer but input tax recoverable. Voluntary registration only for those making taxable supplies below £90,000.
Why the other options fail
- ASurface reading
The company must register and charge VAT on the rents, because its supplies in the last 12 months exceeded the £90,000 registration threshold.
The threshold is measured by taxable supplies. Residential letting is exempt, so nothing counts towards the threshold and no output tax is chargeable.
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, s.4(2) — A taxable supply is a supply other than an exempt supply; supplies of residential land are exempt.
- BAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
The company may register voluntarily, as any business may do, and then recover the £30,000 of input tax.
Voluntary registration is available to a person whose taxable supplies are below the threshold. A person making only exempt supplies cannot register at all.
Ruled out by: The company's only business is residential letting, an exempt supply, so it makes no taxable supplies and voluntary registration is not open to it.
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, s.4(2) — Only supplies other than exempt supplies are taxable supplies; a person making only exempt supplies makes no taxable supplies.
- CRight outcome, wrong reason
The £30,000 is not recoverable unless the contractors issue VAT invoices addressed to the company rather than to its managing agent.
Correcting the invoices would not help: the company makes only exempt supplies, so it cannot register and cannot reclaim input tax at all.
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, s.4(2) — A person making only exempt supplies makes no taxable supplies and so is not a taxable person.
- DAdjacent rule
The rents are zero-rated, so the company may register and recover the £30,000 it has paid.
Residential lettings are exempt, not zero-rated. The distinction matters precisely because a zero-rated supplier can reclaim input tax and an exempt supplier cannot.
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, s.4(2) — Exempt supplies, which include supplies of residential land, are not taxable supplies, unlike zero-rated supplies.