Question 3
Procedures and authority under the Partnership Act 1890MediumThree individuals are partners in an accountancy practice. Their written partnership agreement limits each partner to commitments of £5,000 or less without the others' consent. One partner, writing on the firm's headed notepaper and describing himself as a partner in the practice, agrees to buy a racehorse for £40,000 from a breeder, telling the breeder that the firm is investing in bloodstock. The breeder knows nothing of the practice's internal arrangements.
Which of the following best describes whether the firm is bound by the agreement to buy the racehorse?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
It is not bound, because buying a racehorse is not carrying on, in the usual way, business of the kind carried on by the firm.
Buying a racehorse is not business of the kind carried on by an accountancy practice, so the partner's act does not bind the firm.
A partner's acts bind the firm only where the act is done for carrying on in the usual way business of the kind carried on by the firm. Purchasing bloodstock for £40,000 is no part of an accountancy practice, however the partner described himself and whatever notepaper he used, so the question of the breeder's knowledge of internal limits never arises.
Section 5 binds the firm only where the partner's act is for carrying on in the usual way business of the kind the firm carries on; buying bloodstock is no part of an accountancy practice.
- Partnership Act 1890, s 5 — Acts of a partner for carrying on in the usual way business of the kind carried on by the firm bind the firm, unless the partner had no authority and the third party knew this or did not know or believe him to be a partner.
Rule card
Section 5 has two stages: (1) was the act in the usual way of business of the kind the firm carries on? If not, the firm is not bound. (2) If it was, the firm escapes only if the third party knew of the want of authority or did not know or believe him to be a partner.
Why the other options fail
- BRight outcome, wrong reason
It is not bound, because the partnership agreement limited the partner to commitments of £5,000 or less, and the breeder is fixed with notice of that restriction.
Right outcome, wrong basis: an internal limit does not protect the firm against a third party who is unaware of it, and a third party is not deemed to know a firm's internal terms.
- Partnership Act 1890, s 5 — Want of actual authority avails the firm only where the third party knows of it or does not know or believe the actor to be a partner.
- CRight outcome, wrong reason
It is bound, but the partner who signed must indemnify his fellow partners for the breach of the limit in the partnership agreement, since the firm's liability to the breeder is unaffected.
Breach of an internal limit does give rise to liability between partners, but the prior question is whether the act bound the firm at all, and it did not.
- Partnership Act 1890, s 5 — Whether the firm is bound depends on the act being done in carrying on the firm's usual business.
- DSurface reading
It is bound, because every partner is an agent of the firm and of the other partners.
The agency in s 5 is for the purpose of the business of the partnership; it does not extend to acts outside the kind of business the firm carries on.
- Partnership Act 1890, s 5 — Every partner is an agent of the firm for the purpose of the business of the partnership.
- EAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
It is bound, because the breeder neither knew of nor was told of any limit on the partner's authority to contract.
The proviso about the third party's knowledge only matters once the act is shown to be in the usual way of the firm's kind of business, which this was not.
Ruled out by: The purchase of a racehorse is not business of the kind carried on by an accountancy practice, so the breeder's ignorance of any limit on authority is beside the point.
- Partnership Act 1890, s 5 — The third party's knowledge of a want of authority is relevant only to acts done in carrying on the firm's usual business.